Saving Face and Losing Lives

by Rep. Ron Paul
Published: Oct. 14, 2009 – Antiwar.com

This past week there has been a lot of discussion and debate on the continuing war in Afghanistan. Lasting twice as long as World War II and with no end in sight, the war in Afghanistan has been one of the longest conflicts in which our country has ever been involved. The situation has only gotten worse with recent escalations.

The current debate is focused entirely on the question of troop levels. How many more troops should be sent over in order to pursue the war? The administration has already approved an additional 21,000 American service men and women to be deployed by November, which will increase our troop levels to 68,000. Will another 40,000 do the job? Or should we eventually build up the levels to 100,000 in addition to that? Why not 500,000 – just to be “safe”? And how will the public be brought back around to supporting this war again when 58 percent are now against it?

I get quite annoyed at this very narrow line of questioning. I have other questions. We overthrew the Taliban government in 2001 with less than 10,000 American troops. Why does it now seem that the more troops we send, the worse things get? If the Soviets bankrupted themselves in Afghanistan with troop levels of 100,000 and were eventually forced to leave in humiliating defeat, why are we determined to follow their example? Most importantly, what is there to be gained from all this? We’ve invested billions of dollars and thousands of precious lives – for what?

The truth is it is no coincidence that the more troops we send the worse things get. Things are getting worse precisely because we are sending more troops and escalating the violence. We are hoping that good leadership wins out in Afghanistan, but the pool of potential honest leaders from which to draw has been fleeing the violence, leaving a tremendous power vacuum behind. War does not quell bad leaders. It creates them. And the more war we visit on this country, the more bad leaders we will inadvertently create.

Another thing that war does is create anger with its indiscriminate violence and injustice. How many innocent civilians have been harmed from clumsy bombings and mistakes that end up costing lives? People die from simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time in a war zone, but the killers never face consequences. Imagine the resentment and anger survivors must feel when a family member is killed and nothing is done about it. When there are no other jobs available because all the businesses have fled, what else is there to do but join ranks with the resistance, where there is a paycheck and also an opportunity for revenge? This is no justification for our enemies over there, but we have to accept that when we push people, they will push back.

The real question is: why are we there at all? What do our efforts now have to do with the original authorization of the use of force? We are no longer dealing with anything or anyone involved in the attacks of 9/11. At this point we are only strengthening the resolve and the ranks of our enemies. We have nothing left to win. We are only there to save face, and in the end we will not even be able to do that.

Source: http://original.antiwar.com/paul/2009/10/13/saving-face-and-losing-lives/

 

Related:

Fake Elections Won’t Bring Peace to Afghanistan

Afghanistan and the New Great Game

Af-Pak Is Obama’s War

The Drones Are Coming: New War on Civilians

Documentary – The Oil Factor: Behind the War on Terror

Documentary – An Unholy Alliance

Documentary – Afghan Massacre – The Convoy of Death

VIDEO – The men behind Obama… (Interview with Webster Tarpley)

VIDEO – The Grand Chessboard

VIDEO – Timeline: Afghanistan: John Rees on the history of imperial intervention and resistance

CIA: Secret Operations, Drug Money

Oppose the Afghanistan-Pakistan war

Documentary – Arsenal of Hypocrisy (59 mins.)

Barack Obama pledges to keep U.S. ‘dominance’

NATO celebrates 60th anniversary by expanding Central Asian war

Pentagon Plans For Global Military Supremacy

Expanding the Afghan War: The West’s insatiable appetite for Global Military Domination

Escalation of the Afghan War? US-NATO Target Russia, China and Iran

US-NATO Using Military Might To Control World Energy Resources

Afghanistan: Eight Years and Counting

A War of Absurdity

Eight Years of Big Lies on Afghanistan


8 Comments on “Saving Face and Losing Lives”

  1. How to Make Money using Paypal?
    this is not just another get rich scam it actually works this is not a scam please read on
    Create a Paypal account for free.

    Give six people $1.00. or 50p (Paypal IDs are listed below.)
    Post this opportunity to others on the internet.
    Other people create a Paypal account for free.
    Thousands of people give you $1.00 or 50p to be put on your mailing list.
    (Once you add your Paypal ID.)

    Turn $4 or £2 into $15,000 in only 30 days…heres how! You have most
    likely seen or heard about this project
    on TV programs such as 20/20 and Oprah, or you may have read about
    it in the Wall Street Journal.

    Here are the 4 easy steps to success:
    STEP 1:

    Take a few minutes to join Paypal:.

    http://www.paypal.com

    The Internet’s most trusted Internet banking system for your future
    income.

    STEP 2:

    Once you have a Paypal account running, use Paypal to send $1 or 50p to
    EACH of the 4 Email Addresses below
    because you pay people with an email address in Paypal. Select “SEND
    MONEY”.

    What you are doing is creating a service. This is absolutely legal!
    You are requesting a legitimate service
    and you are paying for it!

    Here are the 4 individual Email addresses that you have to send $1
    to through Paypal for this to work
    properly and for you to receive money.

    (If you don’t send the money and decide to post the message with
    your name in it anyway, Paypal will
    instantly pick this up and terminate your account, immediately,
    besides the other penalties!!)

    If you did this you could get into serious trouble because it is
    fraud. (So follow the instructions and post the
    $4 or £2 and you will make lots of money with no hassles.)

    Now Send $1.00 or 50p to each of the 4 people on the list using Paypal, and
    in the comment (Subject) section type “Please add me to your list”.
    Below are the emails that you transfer the money into:
    Step 3 add your paypal email address to the top of the list and get rid of the one at the botom

    Send $1 or 50p to :
    1.) clare.blackley@ntlworld.com
    2.) jlook222@yahoo.com
    3.) peterblackley@ehitscenter.com
    4.) AMAYA760@yahoo.com
    thank you

  2. […] Saving Face and Losing Lives Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Internal ConflictsWar on Terror: “dumb war?” […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s